Italy should eradicate discrimination and xenophobia and improve its migration policy

Executive Summary

Commissioner Thomas Hammarberg and his delegation visited Italy from 13 to 15 January 2009, as a follow-up to his visit which took place from 19 to 20 June 2008. In the course of this visit the Commissioner held discussions with national and local authorities and non-governmental, national and international organisations on a number of human rights issues including action against discrimination, protection of Roma and Sinti and migration. Among the state authorities that were contacted were the Secretary of State of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs Mr Alfredo Mantica and the Secretary of State of the Ministry of Interior Mr Alfredo Mantovano. In the present Report the Commissioner focuses on the following issues:

I. Action against racism and xenophobia: The Commissioner notes with satisfaction certain positive measures adopted by Italy in order to fight racism and xenophobia, such as the 2008 Law shifting the burden of proof and the education programmes of the Ministry of Education marked by an intercultural approach. However, he remains particularly worried by consistent reports that continue to evidence a trend of racism and xenophobia in Italy, occasionally supported by actions of local authorities, which has led also to violent acts against migrants, Roma and Sinti or Italian citizens of migrant descent. The Commissioner reiterates his recommendation that the authorities ensure a prompt reaction to and strong condemnation of all racist or intolerant manifestations and to reinforce the anti-discrimination legislation. He also recommends that the authorities promote further systematic human rights education and awareness of the police and judicial authorities, establish promptly a national human rights institution and pay particular attention to combating racism in the fields of sports and on the internet.

II. The protection of human rights of Roma and Sinti: The Commissioner welcomes the Italian government’s commitment to continuing to pay due attention to the issues and recommendations made in his Memorandum of July 2008, as well as a number of measures, such as the launching of the Council of Europe DOSTA! Roma awareness campaign and efforts at facilitating access to housing for Roma and children’s education. Nonetheless, his visit last January to five Roma settlements in Rome and the discussions with Roma representatives that he had during this visit tied in with reports showing the continuation of an intolerant climate vis-àvis Roma and Sinti, the lack of an institutionalized dialogue between the authorities and Roma and Sinti and the persistence of unacceptably low standards of living in a number of Roma settlements, especially those inhabited by migrants and their families. The Commissioner is also deeply concerned about the large-scale operation of the census in Roma and Sinti settlements, which were managed by the police and linked to a ‘state of emergency’ and a ‘widespread public alarm’. Whilst noting with satisfaction the commitment showed to him by the Mayor of Rome to have consultations with Roma representatives and by the Interior Ministry Secretary of State to tackle the serious issue of stateless Roma children, the Commissioner urges the authorities to create consultative mechanisms at all levels with Roma and Sinti, avoid evictions without offering alternative housing and adopt and implement a coherent and adequately resourced national action plan in accordance with the Council of Europe recommendations.

III. The protection of human rights of immigrants and asylum seekers: While recognizing the serious challenges that migratory flows present to state mechanisms, the Commissioner continues to follow and to remain very concerned about new legislative measures on immigration and asylum which have been adopted or under consideration by Italy, such as those criminalizing the letting of accommodation to irregular migrants and the decision to lift the ban on doctors to report to the authorities irregular migrants who access the health system. The Interior Ministry’s recent decision to process all asylum applications on and deport irregular migrants from the island of Lampedusa and the subsequent excessive overcrowding of the reception centre therein caused the Commissioner’s serious concern. The Commissioner welcomes the determination shown to him by the authorities during his visit to uphold a high level CommDH(2009)16 of protection to foreign nationals in need thereof and urges them to abide by and disseminate Council of Europe standards concerning forced returns and human rights protection. He urges the authorities to review draft or adopted migration-related pieces of legislation that raise serious issues of compatibility with human rights standards, to pay particular attention to the needs of minor migrants and to ratify promptly the Council of Europe Convention on Action against Trafficking in Human Beings.

IV. Foreign nationals’ forced returns and compliance with the Rule 39 requests of the European Court of Human Rights: The Commissioner remains worried by a number of deportations that have taken place, especially from Italy to Tunisia, and by credible reports showing that on certain occasions the deportees had been subjected to torture in the latter country. Of special concern to the Commissioner have been two such cases where deportations to Tunisia took place in 2008 even though the European Court of Human Rights had indicated interim measures under its Rule 39, requesting Italy to stay deportations while the deportees’ applications were pending before it. Even though the Commissioner is aware of the difficulties faced by member states in their efforts to protect their societies from terrorist violence, he remains deeply concerned by state practices that contravene fundamental European human rights standards such as the one prohibiting in absolute terms torture or inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment. The Commissioner strongly opposes forced returns, even if they occur under cover of diplomatic assurances, to countries with long-standing, proven records of torture. He calls on the Italian authorities to urgently review their policy in this field and effectively conform to the binding interim measures ordered by the European Court of Human Rights. The Italian authorities’ comments on the draft Report are appended. Download at PDF format

English

Report on Italy

French

Rapport sur l’italie